Accessible Meetings, Events & Conferences Guide

Helping you plan and conduct accessible and inclusive meetings, events, and conferences.

Introduction The Market Case for Accessible Events, Meetings and Conferences Site Selection Pre-Event Attendee Registration and Communications Meeting Room Layouts and Considerations Audio Visual Components Food and Beverage Service Food Allergies and Sensitivities Accommodations for Deaf Individuals or Those Experiencing Hearing Loss Access to Printed or Visual Materials Invisible Wounds: Emerging Promising Practices for Meeting Planners Personal Assistants and Service Animals Virtual Meetings Tips for Presenters Tips for Attendees Introduction

Welcome to the updated, digital version of A Guide to Planning Accessible Meetings, originally published by Independent Living Research Utilization in 1993, written by co­-authors June Isaacson Kailes and Darrell Jones. The Mid­-Atlantic ADA Center and TransCen, Inc. sponsored this update and publication in recognition of the 25th anniversary of the transformational Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) of 1990. This version includes regulatory updates along with practical guidance from a host of meeting planning professionals, subject matter experts, and even June Kailes herself. The contents of this guide were developed under a grant from the National Institute on Disability, Independent Living, and Rehabilitation Research (NIDILRR award number 90DP0007). NIDILRR is a Center within the Administration for Community Living (ACL), Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). The contents of this guide do not necessarily represent the policy of NIDILRR, ACL, HHS, and you should not assume endorsement by the federal government. TransCen’s work represents the intersection of grassroots implementation and national policy and initiatives. Since 1996, it has supported the Mid­-Atlantic ADA Center, one of ten regional ADA Centers of the ADA National Network, funded by the National Institute on Disability, Independent Living, and Rehabilitation Research. Our goal is that this guide will help make every meeting, event, and conference accessible. It is with great pleasure that we share this work, which will continue to be updated to best serve the needs of planners, and help ensure that all meeting participants are fully engaged and have equal opportunities to contribute to public discourse, learning, and advancement.

How To Use This Guide

This online guide is an update from a print publication issued in 1993. As a web resource, however, it becomes a living document that can be modified and updated as emerging practices become best practices, and as these practices fold into an ever­-widening circle of gatherings, both professional and personal. Note that information may be repeated in various sections where it may be relevant. The navigation options on the left of the screen are “chapter” titles, and clicking the link will open both introductory text and additional subchapters with more information and resources. Every effort has been made to ensure that links to other online resources are live and unbroken; staff at the Mid­-Atlantic ADA Center will continue to monitor the guide and appreciate hearing from you if broken links are found. Finally, while the ADA is referenced often throughout this document and technical experts have reviewed content, this is not a replacement for competent legal counsel. Rather, the team presents here what is required under the law as understood by these subject matter experts, and promising practices to make YOUR event fully inclusive, a market advantage in today’s competitive and ever-­expanding service economy. By ensuring that all participants have equal access, the world will truly be a richer place. A Note on Language and Terms

“Disability advocates strive for equality, accessibility and acceptance, yet they are continually confronted by language which perpetuates negative stereotypes of who they are. People with disabilities, disability rights activists, service providers, health care providers, writers, reporters, editors, educators and supporters must become aware of the power of language. Are you perpetuating negative attitudes and false stereotypes of people with disabilities with your language?”

~ June Kailes, Language is More Than a Trivial Concern Language evolves, often even faster than some of those who speak it. One might hear the phrase, “the disability community,” and think that all people with disabilities use a common language to define themselves and one another, as well as the various accommodations that may be needed for access and inclusion. This is not the case! Often, even well­-intentioned and well­-informed individuals may fall behind the times and use language that is no longer considered current, respectful, and inclusive. This guide is a living document, and its publishers will attempt to keep it up to date and amended over time. Defining some common terms, and discussing those terms which no longer should be used, is a way to help visitors to the site carry language into the marketplace. Of course, if you are visiting this site and come across terms that are objectionable or offensive to you as a reader, we hope you will share your perspectives so we may consider them for future updates to this guide.

Interacting with People With Disabilities

Preparing yourself, your team, and your facilities for meetings, events, and conferences that are accessible to those with disabilities will likely result in delivering even better customer service and a better experience for all attendees. To be better prepared, you will want “soft skills” to support your event in addition to the structural, technological, and other physical elements needed for accessibility. The Guide authors recommend the “Disability Etiquette” resources from the United Spinal Association, which include a comprehensive guide, videos, and downloadable tip sheets in English, Spanish, and Chinese.

Online Guide Project Team

In addition to one of the original authors of the 1993 A Guide to Planning Accessible Meetings, the 2015 online guide project team includes subject matter experts from the professional meeting planning and accessible design fields, advocates, and individuals with disabilities across a broad spectrum.

Project Contributor, Marian Vessels

Marian Vessels is the retired Director of the Mid-­Atlantic ADA Center. She served in this role for many years, leading the Center’s team in providing training and guidance on the Americans with Disabilities Act. Previously, Ms. Vessels was the Executive Director of the Maryland Governor’s Committee on Employment of People with Disabilities. She also worked as the Director of the Maryland Governor’s Office for Individuals with Disabilities and was an Executive Board Member for the President’s Committee on Employment of People with Disabilities. “I am a wheelchair user who attends many meetings, events and conferences for my job as Director of the Mid­-Atlantic ADA Center,” she said. “I often encounter venues, configurations of rooms, food displays, and other aspects of an event that are not welcoming to me as a participant with a disability. Many of these events were disability-related and should have considered these factors when planning and executing their function.” Prior to this project, Marian said there was no current single source to provide guidance and best practices to these planners. “Some of these issues are ADA­-related, such as the correct number of properly configured parking spaces, while others are best practices to assure the goal of the ADA — full inclusion of those with disabilities into all aspects of American life — is achieved.” It is the goal of the Center to provide information and resources to further the inclusion of participants with disabilities into the meetings, events, and conferences that you are planning. Please do share this resource with those you feel would benefit from it. We feel that this document will go a long way to provide guidance and tools for more inclusive meetings!

Author, June Isaacson Kailes

Author and subject matter expert, June Isaacson Kailes, (www.jik.com (link is external) ), is a Disability Policy Consultant and the Associate Director and Adjunct Associate Professor at Harris Family Center for Disability and Health Policy at Western University of Health Sciences, Pomona, California. Her current work focuses on building disability competencies into the worlds of health care and emergency management. June’s breadth and depth of experience in disability, access, and functional needs issues as a writer, trainer, researcher, policy analyst, subject matter expert, and advocate is widely known and respected. “Much has changed since I and Darrel Jones, with the great support of ILRU, first published A Guide to Planning Accessible Meetings in 1993. The writing of that ‘Guide’ was motivated by the authors’ frustration at observing repeated access barriers at meetings and events. The lessons were observed, but often were not subsequently applied.” The Guide proved helpful to making large dents in the problem. “Parts of our ‘Guide’ have been periodically updated and can be found in diverse pieces and fragments on the Internet,” she says. “This NEW online guide centralizes and modernizes accessible event planning information in an easy to use portal, offering dynamic, scalable, and customizable information for planning small to large events, be it conferences, meetings, receptions or dinners. It can be used for getting a thorough orientation to accessible event planning or getting a few very specific answers to access related questions.” As this is a digital guide rather than a published book, June encourages feedback and suggestions from visitors to the site as they use the resources presented.

Contributor, Kobena A. Bonney

Kobena works out of downtown Boston for the Massachusetts Rehabilitation Commission (MRC). He is the statewide Coordinator of the federally funded Assistive Technology (AT) Act program in Massachusetts called MassMATCH (Massachusetts Maximizing Assistive Technology in Consumers’ Hands). Kobena is a longtime AT user and enthusiast. He has 20-­plus years’ experience using and working with Assistive Technology. His passion is to promote awareness of and affordable access to AT for people with disabilities everywhere. Before coming to work at MRC in 1998, Kobena worked in Toms River, New Jersey for the New Jersey Commission for the Blind and Visually Impaired (CBVI) as a Technological Services Specialist. Among other roles, he conducted AT assessments and made recommendations on appropriate technology to enable CBVI clients to achieve their vocational rehabilitation goals. Between 1999 and 2006, Kobena worked for the Massachusetts Association for the Blind (now MAB Community Services) in three different administrative capacities – ­ NFB­-Newsline Coordinator, Director of Communication Services, and Regional Director of MAB’s operations in Western Massachusetts.

Contributor, Marissa Sanders

Marissa Sanders has worked in disability rights for more than 15 years. She served as Executive Director of the West Virginia Commission for the Deaf and Hard of Hearing and as Director of Training for the Mid-­Atlantic ADA Center. She has also worked at three different Centers for Independent Living and served on the National Council on Independent Living. While at the ADA Center, she trained over 500 people on various aspects of the Americans with Disabilities Act. Ms. Sanders currently serves as an independent consultant and as a Video Interpreter for Sorenson Communications where she interprets phone calls in American Sign Language for individuals who are Deaf or hard of hearing. She lives in Charleston, West Virginia with her husband.

Editor, Angela Strain

Project editor, Angela Strain, has been writing, editing, and presenting education and advocacy materials for more than twenty years in the nonprofit sector, on topics ranging from healthcare to the environment and community organizing. She has helped secure more than $100 million in grant funds for nonprofits across the Southeastern United States. “When the ADA was first passed, the museum system I worked for selected me for training in facility compliance to help advise the team responsible for construction and operation of new attractions, including theaters and education centers,” she says. “From that time to this, advocating for universal accessible design and equal access have been driving passions. This project will help reach a whole new generation of event and meeting hosts, planners, and facilities, with both the letter and the spirit of the law.” She adds, “for me, this work is also personal. With functional needs to be accommodated myself, tackling conferences and meetings can be a challenge; I am eager to see this guide improve the experience of those living with both visible and invisible disabilities and limitations.”

Project Advisor, Sarah Galbraith Laucks, CMP

Consultant, trainer, subject matter expert, and president of Meeting Well, Sarah Galbraith Laucks has been planning conferences for people with disabilities since 1993. In fact, her connections to disability go back even further, to the late 1970s when her childhood best friend had intellectual disabilities. Her career includes eight years with Hilton Hotels and five years with Hershey Entertainment & Resorts. Sarah’s varied background has equipped her with skills in conference management, website and email marketing, VIP visits, special events, committee facilitation, and professional speaking and writing. She specializes in access for people with disabilities and eco-­friendly initiatives for the meetings industry. “While June Kailes’ guide has been a bible for those of us planning accessible meetings on a day­-to­-day basis, the professional meeting and hospitality industry is quite large and a majority have not been aware of her work. There’s been a void in the industry’s certification and training programs – no one place for these professionals to turn for answers to their questions, accurate information and guidance on how to make their meetings accessible. Beyond the need to accommodate attendees with disabilities of a certain level, the reality is that many attendees have some type of disability they face. Examples include low vision, hearing loss, dietary needs, food allergies, difficulty walking long distances and temporary, significant disability. Providing tools to make accessible meetings an every­day consideration will serve to take the meetings industry to the next level in producing inclusive, meaningful events.” Sarah holds a Bachelor of Science in education, graduating summa cum laude from Susquehanna University, and is a recipient of the Certified Meeting Professional designation from the Convention Industry Council. Personal interests include animal rescue, nutrition and wellness, and figure skating. She is a member of Pennsylvania Association for Sustainable Agriculture and the Center for Independent Living of Central Pennsylvania Board of Directors.

Graphic Designer, Patrick Florville

Formerly a pre-med student, Patrick Florville is an award-winning brand strategist and creative director of Florville Catalyst, Inc., based in New York City. With over 30 years’ experience, he has created branding and communication solutions for an impressive clientele across a broad range of industries, from small businesses and non-profits to Fortune 500 corporations. As a parent of a child with a disability, he brings passion and commitment to organizations and causes which embrace diversity and disability inclusion, empowering them with a compelling presence amidst their largest competitors. Patrick’s work has won national and international awards, and is part of the permanent collection of the Smithsonian Institute National Museum of Design at the Cooper Hewitt.

Additional Acknowledgements

The Project Team wishes to thank a number of organizations and individuals who have provided input and comment on the creation of this guide, including: Lou Ann Blake, Managing Editor, Journal of Blindness Innovation and Research (link is external) , National Federation of the Blind Lise Hamlin, Director of Public Policy, Hearing Loss Association of America (link is external) Abby Fitzsimmons, Vice President – Membership, United Spinal Association (link is external) Mary Lamielle, Executive Director, National Center for Environmental Health Strategies, Inc.

The Market Case for Accessible Events, Meetings and Conferences

While the U. S. Department of Labor estimates that individuals with disabilities control more than $200 billion in discretionary spending, this figure is likely much less than the true market power of all individuals with functional needs to be accommodated. In fact, many Americans who would benefit from a fully accessible meeting, event, or conference environment may not identify their needs as a “disability.” Scroll through the population notes below and see if you don’t find yourself one degree (or less) from someone who may benefit from the promising practices presented in this guide. The Market Case for Accessible Meetings

Americans with Disabilities: 57.6 Million

According to the U.S. Census, 57.6 million Americans reported having a disability in the 2010 American Community Survey (published July 2012).

Vision: 20.6 Million

According to the 2012 National Health Interview Survey (NHIS) Preliminary Report, an estimated 20.6 million adult Americans (or nearly 10% of all adult Americans) either “have trouble” seeing, even when wearing glasses or contact lenses, or are blind or unable to see at all (source: the American Foundation for the Blind).

Hearing: 30 Million

One in eight people in the United States (13%) aged 12 years or older has hearing loss in both ears, based on standard hearing examinations (National Institute on Deafness and other Communication Disorders).

Mobility: 8 Million

According to the University of Kentucky Human Development Institute, there are approximately 8 million Americans who have some type of mobility impairment that necessitates the use of adaptive equipment such as a cane, crutches, walker, wheelchair, or scooter.

Cognitive/Developmental: 60 Million

There are 60 million Americans nationwide with learning and attention issues (National Center for Learning Disabilities). The Journal of Pediatrics reports that one in six, or about 15%, of children aged 3 through 17 years have one or more developmental disabilities. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) Autism and Developmental Disabilities Monitoring (ADDM) Network reports that 1 in every 68 children in the U.S. has autism spectrum disorder (ASD).

Autoimmune: 23.5 Million

The National Institutes of Health (NIH) estimate there are up to 23.5 million Americans with autoimmune disorders, including multiple sclerosis, lupus, rheumatoid arthritis, and more.

Cancer: 1.6 Million

In 2014, an estimated 1,665,540 new cancer cases were diagnosed (American Cancer Society). In the U.S., 14.5 million children and adults with a history of cancer were alive on January 1, 2014.

Veterans: 2.3 Million

Approximately 20% (2,313,600 out of 11,462,900) of non-­institutionalized civilian veterans aged 21 to 64 years reported having a service­-connected disability in the United States in 2012.

Cardiovascular: 80 Million

An estimated 80 million Americans have one or more types of heart disease (The Heart Foundation).

Diabetes: 29.1 Million

The CDC reports 29.1 million people with diabetes living in the U.S.

Arthritis: 51.8 Million

The CDC reports 51.8 million non-­institutionalized adults with diagnosed arthritis (2012).

Respiratory: 19.6 Million

The CDC reports 6.8 million adults diagnosed with Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) in the past year, 8.7 million with chronic bronchitis, and 4.1 million with emphysema.

Aging Baby Boomers: 77 Million

CNN reports 77 million Americans are part of the aging “Baby Boom” generation (born between 1946 and 1964). They represent roughly 24.3% of the total population.

Temporary

Have you ever broken a limb? Recovered from surgery? Been in a car wreck? Picture yourself here! Site Selection

Sites constructed after the ADA was passed should generally meet the ADA’s facility standards. Those standards were updated in 2010, and sites constructed after March 2012 will meet the new 2010 Standards for Accessible Design. (link is external) Sites that comply with the older ADA standards and have not been altered are also considered “accessible.” However, if existing facilities, or parts of them (whether they comply with the older standards or were built before the passage of the ADA) are altered, then the altered areas must comply with the new standards to the maximum extent structurally feasible. Existing facilities that are not altered must still improve accessibility. Private businesses must remove structural barriers where it is “readily achievable” to do so, meaning where it is “easily accomplishable and able to be carried out without much difficulty or expense.” Existing structural conditions, costs, and the financial resources of a particular business must be considered, so what is readily achievable will vary from one business to another. Additionally, since the obligation is ongoing, things that are not readily achievable at a certain point in time may become achievable at a future time. You should always ask about the accessibility of facilities when considering event venues. Not all facility sales representatives will know about the accessibility features of their facilities. Hotels, however, are specifically required to keep detailed information about the accessibility of their properties. This includes public spaces like meeting rooms, restaurants, lobbies, and parking lots, as well as accessible overnight guest rooms and other guest amenities such as fitness rooms or swimming pools. Since hotels must provide this information to potential guests seeking to make reservations, they should have no trouble producing it for meeting planners. Choose facilities that are protected by audible and visible fire alarms and a fire sprinkler system. The U.S. Fire Administration has a list of hotels and motels approved for federal travelers (link is external) which can be helpful in identifying properties that have certain safety features. Facilities that have ground floor meeting rooms with accessible paths directly to the outside are also preferable, as this may allow greater numbers of individuals to evacuate independently. Many meeting planners hire consultants to assess potential event venues, especially for very large or complex events that may involve multiple or specialized facilities. But if you want to assess a facility yourself, the New England ADA Center offers an ADA Checklist for Existing Facilities (link is external) . This user-­friendly tool is filled with helpful diagrams and illustrations and includes instructions for use. The checklist contains a basic section that will allow you to review spaces such as parking lots, entrances, and public restrooms, as well as several sections on recreational facilities such as swimming pools and golf courses. You may wish to include an affirmative statement of compliance, or allocation of responsibilities between landlord and tenant, in any rental agreements or contracts you enter with meeting venues. This can help both parties understand their responsibilities, particularly if any temporary measures will be taken to ensure access during your event. This section of the Guide will explore more specific elements of event planning that will help you make your event as accessible as possible.

Local Resources To Assist Your Planning Efforts

What Does Your Event Need? Creating a Needs Assessment

Before reaching out to facilities to find the best choice for your event, you need to identify the needs of your audience. Here are some things to consider:

Request for Bid

Once you have identified your needs and narrowed the venue list to three to five choices, call or email the venue sales offices with your specific requirements and request a proposal. It is important in the initial contact to identify the needs you’ve outlined, as the venue’s responsiveness to your needs in their proposal can be telling.

Evaluating Bids / Responses

Create a “scoring system” to help you and your team rank each venue. You can use your Needs Assessment to determine your criteria and decide which items deserve more weight than others. For example, you might decide to rank location over price, or availability of an accessible fitness center over the number of restaurants in the vicinity. Choose a scale that is easy to use and calculate. As in the example below, each team member can be asked to rank each criterion from one to five, with five being best and one being the worst. Compare your team’s rankings to determine the two or three sites you will visit in the selection process.

Sample Grid For Recording Scores - Use to help evaluate more than one response to your request for bid from conference sites, hotel, or event venues. Use your needs assessment to detail out each criteria.

Site Inspection

Once you have scored the top two to three venues, you should visit each to continue the evaluation process. When possible, plan at least two visits to each venue. The first visit should be unannounced to the facility’s sales team.

Visit the common areas, have coffee or a meal at a lobby restaurant, walk any of the grounds that are open to the public, assess the parking lot, review access to sidewalks, safety features like call boxes or shuttle service from distant lots, proximity to public transportation, and other “first impression” criteria. You can use your notes from this visit during your scheduled appointment with the venue’s sales team the next time you are on site. If there are concerns that their team cannot fix for your meeting, you will have good information in hand as you make your final choice of location.

Pay attention to your senses during the site visit. Healthy indoor air does not have an odor. Are you aware of fragrances and scents from “air fresheners,” deodorizers, or potpourri? Is your nose or throat burning from chlorine, formaldehyde, or other solvents? Are your sinuses and breathing impacted by mustiness? Even pervasive or lingering cooking odors can be a sign of poor or inadequate ventilation. Note that attendees may have allergies, asthma, sinus problems, frequent headaches and migraines, or chemical sensitivities, and may not be able to successfully participate in your meeting, event, or conference if air quality is poor.

Emergency Planning

Emergency planning must be done well in advance for all events, and it is important to know that facilities and their staff members are prepared.

During your inspection, be sure to ask about the facility’s emergency procedures and policies related to individuals with disabilities: